The Fair Call

Australian Politics & Current Affairs

Black Armbands and White Blindfolds – The Truth About Australia Day

By Nick Kenny

“White man came across the sea, he bought us pain and misery, he killed our tribes, he killed our creed, he took our game for his own need” – Iron Maiden, “Run to the Hills”

Australia Day has become a day that divides. Two loud voices shouting across a great divide, one representing the “black armband” view, the other, the “white blindfold”. The former see it as a day of mourning, a shameful exercise in arrogant nationalism at the expense of aboriginals. “Invasion Day”, it is said, ought to be the moniker for the day the evil white man set foot on this island and set about doing his evils deeds. Blind to the reality of history, they have isolated our own experience as some horrible aberration, a millstone of shame forever upon our necks. The latter, by contrast, deny the history books, seeing Australian settlement as a morally triumphant day, the first step in an unblemished and proud history to be celebrated with reckless abandon. The truth, as always, lies in the grey area between.

Let’s call a spade a spade – white settlement was an invasion. Whitefellas came, took the blackfellas’ land, wreaking havoc and spreading disease as they did so. This is a fact denied only by a handful of die-hard revisionists.

However, it is also a fact held in unjust contempt by many modern aboriginals and guilt-ridden apologists. Take a quick glance at history, and you’d be hard pressed to find a corner of the globe that hasn’t had something similar happen – it was the primal nature of humanity until the twentieth century.

Never before in human history have we had the binding international peace treaties, human rights conventions we have today, nor the general inclination to avoid war, colonial conquest, and imperialist violence. The entire narrative of human civilisation, up until very recently, has been that “might is right” – one either conquers and grows, or perishes at the hands of those who do.

Australian settlement occurred at the pinnacle of the imperial European age, when empires clamoured for colonial conquests, with the ultimate goal of global domination. The biggest threats to our European forebears were their own neighbours, frantically building empires of their own and warring amongst one other incessantly. The alternative to building an empire of their own was to perish at the hands of whoever else beat them to it.

We would do well to remember that one year after Arthur Phillip set foot on Australian soil, the French overthrew their monarch, and set off a chain of events that would lead directly to Napoleon Bonaparte, a decimated European continent at the hands of the French imperialists, with the tiny British isles desperately clamouring to mount a defense. This was, quite bluntly, the dog-eat-dog world of the eighteenth century.

Were it not the British who conquered aboriginal land for their crown, then without a doubt it would have been the French, the Spanish, the Portuguese, or the Dutch. This was the reality of the age in which we were settled. It was grim, it is nothing to reflect upon with any sense of pride, but it was the unavoidable nature of the world at the time.

Finally, an inconvenient truth ignored by the apologists is the fact that we have brought a great deal to aboriginal life. The myth of the “traditional” way of life, being some peaceful and prosperous Garden of Eden, has no substance in fact. Our health services, housing, and social welfare have all been bulwarks against the unforgiving life in the Australian bush. Life expectancy has improved dramatically, infant mortality has plummeted, and life overall is a more comfortable and stable existence.

This may or may not be an ideal substitute – no one wants their entire culture overhauled and replaced – but the balance sheet of rights and wrongs now sits well in our favour. Moreover, we did not introduce violence – tribal warfare was prevalent here long before Britain even existed as a political entity.

It is the height of arrogance to judge the brutality of the past through the enlightened lens of modern values and institutions. Rather than anguish over the violence that has governed our existence on this planet since the dawn of time, we ought to be proud of our ability to transcend it. Enjoy Australia Day – I know I will.



4 comments on “Black Armbands and White Blindfolds – The Truth About Australia Day

  1. Jim
    January 28, 2013

    ‘…the balance sheet of rights and wrong ow sits well in our favour’?
    I’m sure a lot of people would dispute that claim!! How does one come to that conclusion anyway?

    • toosmartbyhalf
      March 7, 2013

      Well Jim, typically the life expectancy of native tribes sat far below where it is now with the advent of modern Western medicine. Infant mortality rates were horrendous for all peoples, not just aboriginals, up until the twentieth century, but they’ve now plummeted. These two factors alone are cause for celebration. Add to this a civilised legal structure, free secular education, housing provisions, protection against starvation, the end of tribal warfare, and exposure to the diverse cultures of the outside world.

      There are clearly detriments also – the debasement of their culture, the introduction of alcohol and tobacco, the clearing of native lands, incarceration, brutality, and prejudice at the hands of the police.

      My argument is that both the “black armband” and the “white blindfold” views are unhelpful simplifications, each composed by politicised groups, and serve no cause other than to divide along mythical and false ideas. The reality is more complex. I is our job to acknowledge and rectify the negatives, while paying respect to the positives and continuing to build upon them.

  2. Pingback: Fear and loathing in the land down under | Too Smart By Half

  3. Jacques
    July 19, 2014

    Smoking cigarettes is no more guilt in indulging in a” smoke” them
    because your hair and clothes. Some people are apprehensive about
    using these products because they have firmly decided to quit smoking, it
    is nnot made with paper nor is niotine vaporizer cigarette there a lengthywarning for smokersposted on the site.
    Just don’t give up. Smokinng definitely gives immense pleasure nicotine
    vaporizer cigarette annd a habituated smoker finds it almost impossibleto stop smoking even when his health is failing.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: